809 S. Meadow St., Ithaca, NY 14850 • (607) 227-6489

Our name says it all...We sell only cars
we consider to be a top value.

Why buy from Top 5?

Our mission

At Top 5 Rated Used Cars it is our mission to sell only top rated cars for the buying public to purchase.  As our name says, we sell only those cars that are highly rated and provide the most value for the buyer. A high percentage of repeat business after 20 years gives us great pride that our original mission to sell only the top rated cars has proven to be a well accepted business practice.  We hope to see you soon at Top 5 Rated.

Lines at the dmv? paperwork?

At Top 5, we go to the Department of Motor Vehicles in person for you. We can also accept finance applications and submit them right from the dealership. We make everything as easy as possible for you.

Monday through Friday 9:30 - 5:30
Saturday 10:00 - 4:00

Send us an E-mail


Top 5 Rated Used Cars

Bob Tottey - Owner

809 South Meadow Street

Ithaca, NY 14850

(607) 227-6489